The Stories We Tell

The Stories We Tell Ourselves

Habit is habit, and not to be flung out of the window by any man, but coaxed down-stairs a step at a time.  Mark Twain

Not long ago a friend, Rachel, phoned me in tears. She’d spent all day in despair—a Sabbath, and therefore a full, free day to reflect on how useless, worthless, and defective she was, and, how depressed!  It’s not unusual. I know people who would not speak to a dog the way they talk to themselves.

From earliest childhood her mentally-ill mother had instilled the message that Rachel was no good, unloved, fated for failure, even wicked, vile. It was probably the same story that had been told the mother (and therefore mentally ill?), passed down from generation to generation since the Middle Ages.

Once years ago in writing group, I remarked how sometimes I fell into depressions that lasted for days.

“What do you do in those low times?” asked my friend Natalie with genuine curiosity.

“Why, I do what anyone would! I scold and whip myself to stop being lazy, to get to work.”

“Oh no!” she cried in horror. “You must never do that! When you are feeling poorly, you must put your arm around your shoulder and talk baby talk to yourself; you hug a teddy bear and kiss and love yourself. Never scold!”  I was astonished. No one had ever suggested such a weird idea, but a few weeks later, when I was next feeling blue, I took her advice. . .  and to my surprise, my depression lifted instantly.

I was shocked!

This information is as important as the suggestion that I should not allow myself to stray into what I call the Garden of Rejection, with its pretty, white, picket fence and brilliant flowers all calling out to me to enter and play at self-pity. I used to push open the gate, take one step inside – and BINGO! I was Lost! I might wander in Rejection for three days before stumbling through the gate by accident, panting with exhaustion and promising never, never to go inside again. (I wish I could say I kept the promise, but it was easily forgotten, for from early childhood I indulged in the pleasure of eating worms, the comforting self-pity that comes from playing with Rejection. Many tears were happily spent in childhood hugging my knees and thinking of my parents that– “You’ll be sorry when I die!” I would take this vengeance – and then enjoy the poignant bittersweet image of watching myself at my own funeral and the sorrow of the aunts).

But I was talking about the stories we tell. “You are what you think,” wrote the Buddha. “Believe, and all things are possible,” said Christ (or something like that). Think you are weak, pathetic, indecisive, and you will be. Think you are strong, confident, intuitive, guided, successful… and all the forces of the Universe will combine to make it so. I guess this is one of the three or four things I’d want my grandchildren to know.

Our stories can be changed. A friend, Nancy Denig, works with men in prison, offering a ten week course in “Decisional Training,” which teaches prisoners to recognize the stories they tell (“I’m no good; I’m bad”) and to change tit, as well as teaching how to respond to conditions instead of thoughtlessly react.

Not all the prisoners succeed in shifting perceptions, but in a follow-up session one man observed that he’d discovered he wasn’t a bad person. He had done bad things, but he wasn’t bad. Another found that he was deeply loved! My daughter works with vets with PTSD, and she finds this same self-excoriation among the survivors who’ve seen their buddies blown to bits. Is self-hatred the Original Sin?

When we change our story, we change the past. This website,, is worth a look.  Byron Katie is brilliant in identifying and questioning the thoughts that cause all the anger, fear, depression, addiction, and violence in the world. So I’m urging Rachel to watch the videos. She’s ready. Even just phoning me that night was a beginning, the recognition that she was doing something wrong—that something had to change—that she was miserable and being invited by her Higher Self , by the Universe Itself, to turn her mind from hatred to its true, awakened, peaceful and creative state.

7 thoughts on “The Stories We Tell

  1. Dear Sophy,

    Thank you and Yes yes yes it was a good day. I think I mentioned that my car needs to be fixed and therefore I am staying in Charlottesville until such is done, and with a nice friend. Took Ann and Merry for lunch and shopping etc. today and we had a delovely time: I hope you had the same with your girls/grandgirls.

    I will listen to that when the computer lets me: I have always loved Paul and Galatians was prescient. Thank you. Keep thinking about St. F prayer — unerstand/forgive rather than to be understood/be forgiven. Honestly, in those dichotomies — well, who could ever both understand AND forgive me?! (I always trip up in the Lord’s Prayer over “forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive… ” — I am awful at forgiveness.



  2. Good Morning,
    Peace on this great Independence Day we call the 4th of July. It’s difficult to know how to respond to this type of story. With respect to depression, my only advice is simply to find what inspires you and if you can remember even one word of comfort that you have ever offered to another, even when you were at a loss for words, offer that same word of comfort to yourself.

    “Faith is the substance of things hoped for and the evidence of things unseen,” is a quotation from Hebrews. (Sorry, I don’t remember chapter and verse at the moment.) So simply know that eventually your life can return to a normal one and ignore the opinions of others who think that they know better. Doctors have knowledge about medicine but it’s up to you to write the next chapter of the book you always wanted to write or simply take care of the next routine task or take the next step in recovering from an illness. Sometimes families just need even well intentioned volunteers to back off a little and give them room to find their own way to heal and take care and you and your daughter have more than sufficient wisdom and grace to know that. I’m certain you are both doing a great job with that effort. (It’s admirable that you wish to help and encourage them and share your gifts through your writing.)

    I remember a story that my own Mom told me many years ago about her Mom, our grandmother. The doctors had told my grandmother that she would never walk again after a stroke. My grandmother, who was so strong and who had a quick wit regardless of circumstances apparently knew differently and she told them “Oh yes I will!” And eventually, she did. I lost my own Mom back in January of this year but I’m comforted by old family photos of her and the rest of us in better times. I saw her struggle to walk sometimes but she always found a way to take the next step.

    All of us have a degree of resilience. Find it and the rest of life will take care of itself. Take care and be strong and know that you will be well.

  3. So true, Sophy, so true! The kinder self-talk works like magic. I first heard about it from Neil Fiore’s THE NOW HABIT, and it got me through writing my novel.

  4. Byron Katie says any, and I emphasize any stress is caused by believing thoughts that are not true for us.

    Sophy, my opinion is, when you fall into depression you are believing a thought that is not true for you. You are most probably agreeing with something that an authority figure, most likely a parent, foisted on you when you were a small child. Any you are still believing this lie.

Please feel free to leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s